Download Printer-friendly Version
Transcript
• The fourth major change was, in fact, the introduction of an automatic calibration algorithm for the model. Specifically, we applied a mono-objective calibration procedure using the particle swarm optimization algorithm (Kennedy and Eberhart (1995), Eberhart and Shi (2001)). The calibration module is itself a reusable component of the JGrass-NewAge System. Furthermore, all minor typing errors have been corrected and suggestions from reviewers accepted; information about the features of the river basin and about the GIS udig-JGrass have been added as requested by reviewers. C640 2 Answers to P. Krause (Referee) (Q): Abstract: You mention that the system is able to estimate evapotranspiration (line 6) why don’t you use this in your model application. Same is true for snow modeling – not mentioned at all in the application part. Snow must be an important component in your catchment. (A): For the revised text the simulations were repeated and evapotranspiration was computed with the Priestley-Taylor model. Given that snow modelling requires detailed validation and because snow is an important component of the water budget for many months of the year at the Passer river basin, we decided to change the basin of study and use theLittle Washita river basin, Oklahoma (U.S.), instead. Therefore, the paper can concentrate on the presentation and analysis of runoff generation and propagation/routing components. (Q):Page 945, Line 5: ”whole set of hydrological quantities” is not very informative, please be more precise what you mean. (A): The sentence under review is: ”Models developed to reproduce a whole set of hydrological quantities for operational purposes came from water resource management and agriculture needs.” The sentence has been changed to: ”The water resource and river management required however the need to estimate a whole set of hydrological quantities (such as discharge, evapotraspiration, soil moisture) bringing very soon to the implementation of more comprehensive modeling systems, as the pioneering Stanford watershed model (Crawford and Linsley (1966)), or like the Sacramento model (e.g. Burnash et al. (1973)), the PRMS model (Leavesley et al. (1983))”. (Q):Line 29: Please indicate how you define “an acceptable degree of confidence” C641